Home / Uncategorized / A Tu B’shvat Thought

A Tu B’shvat Thought

By Nina-Beth Cardin

Trees are the symbol of the Garden of Eden, the Paradise of creation. Among all the deeds that God did to bring forth life in Eden, we are explicitly told that God planted a garden there and the trees that grew there. But these weren’t just any trees. God planted fruit trees.

In Deuteronomy 20, we are told that Israelites laying siege to a city may not cut down trees to aid in their siege. But this injunction is not about just any trees. It expressly forbids the cutting of fruit trees. While this verse is taken as the founding law that has spawned an extensive legal category forbidding wanton destruction, we may also learn one other fundamental principle from it. We may not destroy one Paradise to win another.

No matter how attractive or compelling the city that we wish to occupy appears, no matter how compelling or attractive a world we wish to create seems to us in our imagination, we cannot and must not destroy the paradise that is before us for a chimera that plays within our mind. For in truth, when finally won or purchased or created, this chimera will sooner or later bore us or disappoint us, and we will ache to be off on another adventure, another siege, another conquest, another destruction. The constancy of the fruit trees tells us that we can only build a future paradise in the midst of our present paradise. Or else it can’t be built at all.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.